There are a bewildering number of opinions as to what constitutes Russian Dressing, so many in fact that one might be tempted to say that this can't be considered an actual, defined item in the kitchen.
But then, without Russian Dressing, there'd be no such thing as a Reuben Sandwich or a Crab Louie Salad, so someone out there must be sure that what they're using is "Russian Dressing."
The most common versions are based on mayonnaise and a tomato sauce. A quick and dirty version of Russian Dressing is mayonnaise and tomato ketchup. A step-up is mayonnaise and a chunky chili sauce, which starts to add texture and interest to the sauce. Better versions seem to go the next step of adding minced pimiento, minced green pepper, minced onion, etc. Some recipes go beyond that even and add chopped boiled egg.
But you can't rely too much on the mayonnaise component: some recipes use salad oil and vinegar in an emulsification (sometimes red wine vinegar) as the base, to which is added the chili sauce, minced onion, chopped egg, etc.
A relatively safe definition of Russian Dressing would seem to be a somewhat creamy, pinkish sauce, based on oil and vinegar -- whether the oil and vinegar come in the form of pre-emulsified mayonnaise, or whether they are emulsified while making the dressing. Egg is very often a component -- whether in the mayonnaise, or whether added in chopped form, or both. There is most likely to be some kind of tomato component to it, giving it both part of its taste, and its colour. Generally, better versions should have somewhat of a sharp taste to them, either from ingredients such as chili sauce, Tabasco, or pimiento.
Bottled versions are made by companies such as Kraft, Seven Seas and Wishbone.
In addition to of course being used as a salad dressing, Russian Dressing is used as an ingredient in many dishes.
Russian Dressing bears no relation to Russian Salad.
The recipe for Russian Dressing, though, is entirely American. Disregard anything you hear about the recipe ever having had caviar in it. The recipe was used from the start by ordinary householders.
The first printed version of the recipe we have found, dating from 1900, contains no tomato or chili sauce, though it calls for Tabasco, which would give the dressing a piquant, pinkish hue. This recipe also seems quite thin, as opposed to creamy, though matters get confused when it is served with a mayonnaise sauce poured over it.
[Ed: so the next time someone drones on about authentic Russian Dressing, you can now say the oldest reference you're aware of intends for it to be served with tripe. That should close most such conversations down in a hurry.]
By the time the 1910s roll on, the idea of mayonnaise and chili sauce together for Russian Dressing seems firmly entrenched across the county.
Salad DressingsAemono; Boiled Dressing; Caesar Salad; Green Goddess Dressing; Mayonnaise; Miracle Whip; Ranch Dressing; Russian Dressing; Salad Cream; Salad Dressings; Thousand Island Dressing
Please share this information with your friends. They may love it.