Barbequing a pig
© Roy Schuurhuis
Barbequers tend to hold very strong opinions about what does and does not qualify as barbeque.
Most people use the word "barbeque" to mean anything cooked on an outdoor grill. Included in that number are Brits, Australians, New Zealanders, and Canadians. If you're one of the people who uses the word "barbeque" in that kind of generic way, you need to be very careful not to use it like that around people from the American South. If you're very unlucky, you'll just get the hour-long talking-to about what constitutes proper barbeque. If you're very lucky, they'll feed you as well to illustrate the difference.
People in the Southern States make a distinction between barbequing and what they would call grilling. For them, barbequing is "low and slow" and by slow, they mean anywhere from 4 or 5 hours up to 18 hours, over actual smouldering wood, in a pit. It usually involves cheaper, tougher cuts of meat that develop beautifully with this type of cooking. Think of their barbeque pits as a real man's version of a Crock Pot.
Barbequing a pig
© Roy Schuurhuis
Why do people use a flipper to press down on meat while it's cooking? And people don't just do it on the barbeque; they do it while pan-frying, too. Basically what they are doing is pressing all the juice out of the meat. The worst is when they do it to hamburgers, helping them to turn out nice and dry. Perhaps people do it just because they are standing there with the flipper and are bored.
Ideally, use tongs to flip stuff. Never, however, use a fork, as it pierces the meat and lets all the juices drain out.
Make sure you use separate everything for uncooked meat and fish -- separate plates, knives, forks, etc. Never place cooked meat on a plate it was on before it was cooked. Don't cut cooked meat on a cutting board you just used for the raw (unless you have washed it well, first). If you've ever heard stories of people getting food poisoning from barbeques, not doing this could be one of the prime reasons.
Don't attempt to be thrifty by reusing marinades, sauces, etc, that the raw meat was in. You're not saving any money with a trip to the hospital and weeks off work. Some people say if you boil the marinade, you can re-use it, but what would that do to its flavour? Pitch it.
It is, however, certainly Americans who truly defined and popularized the barbeque. By the end of the colonial period, barbeque was already a tradition in the American South. In the 50 years leading up to the Civil War, plantation owners entertained with great barbeques, at which even the slaves would be fed. After the Civil War, and with the demise of the plantations, large barbeques moved to church picnics and political gatherings. It was a classless and raceless type of gathering, as the meat -- almost always pork -- was cheap, and everyone loved it. Even during the period of racial tension in the American south in the 1950s and 1960s, whites would sneak into some black-owned barbeque restaurants because they felt the barbeque was better there.
Literature & Lore
"I'm a man. Men cook outside. That outdoor grilling is a manly pursuit has long been beyond question. If this wasn't understood, you'd never get grown men to put on those aprons with pictures of dancing weenies on the front, and messages like 'Come 'n' Get It!' " -- William Geist
The confusion over what word to use -- grill or barbeque -- isn't just limited to English speakers.
German seems to use the word "Grill" for both barbeque and grilling. To barbeque something is "etwas auf dem Grill kochen"; to go to a barbeque is "wir gehen zu einer Grillparty".
In an article in the French newspaper "Le Figaro", 24 May 2003 by Martine Albertin et al, three separate words ("gril", "barbecue", and "braise") are used in the space of 3 lines. The 3 words are italicized below:
- "Sur le gril "
- Voici venu le temps où l'on échange volontiers ses fourneaux contre un barbecue.
- Un coin de pelouse, une terrasse, une poignée d'amis, quelques recettes originales à cuisiner sur la braise...
SourcesOzersky, Josh. Barbecuers, Unite! Why Gas Grills Are Evil. New York: Time Magazine. 25 May 2011
BarbequeBarbeque Sauce; Barbeque; Branding Iron; Grilling Basket; Mesquite; Rotisserie; Skewers; Spiedies; Spit
Please share this information with your friends. They may love it.
Also called:Barbecue (French); Barbacoa (Spanish); Churrasco (Portuguese)